Is Jamaica really A Happy Country?
Since the result of the Happy Planet Index (HPI) showing Jamaicans as the third happiest people on earth behind Dominican Republic and Costa Rica there have been many questions as to its authenticity. Many, including Jamaicans, have criticized and even ridiculed the findings.
The rationale is that Jamaica has so much crimes and poverty how could it command such an astonishing position on the Happy Index scale? The irony is that, is for this reason why many of the counties in the top ten of the report are poor South American countries and not rich G8 countries. Happiness and material wealth are not synonymous by any means. Having millions in the bank and a big house are vehicles that contribute to happiness but it does not guarantee happiness by any means. If this were the case, why do so many wealthy people commit suicide?
Happiness is a state of mind that can be achieved based on the expectations that one has. Some people are happy with just providing tonight’s dinner for their family. While others can be miserable because they could not purchase that shiny BMW that their neighbor has. I see many college educated middle class people unable to sleep at night due to mountain of credit cards debts and superficial unattainable and unrealistic goals. Again, to me, happiness is a mental state.
Despite the crime and poverty tourists flock Jamaica yearly. They see something that many of us cannot see. They are wondering how can people with so little resources greet them with such fervor, smiles, friendly faces and such outstanding hospitality? No wonder we say ‘Jamaica, no problem man.’
Filed under: Current Affairs
Like this post? Subscribe to my RSS feed and get loads more!
“Is Jamaica really A Happy Country? ”
This article was published in the ‘Jamaica Gleaner’ on 7/11/09 and these are the responses from the Gleaner readers. You can join the discussion by leaving your comment in our comment box;
***I find this so hilarious. Everyone, including you has been commenting on this report without ever reading it or finding out what was their criteria for determine a happy place. On one side we have people ridiculing the report because “Happy people don’t set records for killing each other”, on the other side we have people defending the report on the grounds that Happiness comes from inside.
The reality is you are all wrong. The report is a measure of our development impact on the environment. Building cities and Factories? Not happy. Tourism and spear fishing? Very Happy. In short, this is a measure of underdevelopment.
Why did the authors call it a happy planet index? I don’t know but if I was to hazard a guess, they are as amused by uninformed debate as I am.
Kevin.
***Wonderful letter. Since the HPI report was published I’ve heard all these intellectuals trying to analyze the reason why it’s almost impossible for Jamaica to be placed at such a high level of happiness with regards to our economic and moral crisis. Yet you came along and summed it up in a simple statement that “Happiness and material wealth are not synonymous by any means”
Had they also watched an interview from CNN when the reporter questioned a little girl from India where the movie “Slumdog Millionaire” was filmed they would have seen a barefoot ten year old girl in rags living in a village filled with dirt and mud huts saying “we are poor but we are happy here.”
Good job
Keith
***I cannot decide whether I should tremble with rage or laugh in disbelief at your letter to the editor.
It still amazes me that it is always the Jamaicans who have fled Jamaica, to their safe and orderly adopted countries where the rule of law is respected, yes, those same ones think all is well with Jamaica. The island gets more beautiful when they have left it, and it becomes “Jamaica land we love”.
So why did they leave, then?
Tell me about happiness on an island where one-third of the population are squatters, have no sanitation nor running water and throw their body waste scandal bags in gullies or in the yards of neighbors they don’t like. Tell me about happiness where murders are causing people even in upper class areas to feel fear, and children go to school with one hand on the cellphone just in case they’re threatened with abduction. Where minimum wage is 50 American dollars per week, and most food items — almost everything — is imported and sold more expensive than in the States; where the JPS and NWA play havoc with your bills and there is just no recourse, no willing ear to listen to your distress.
Well, Jamaicans must be happy when they start killing white people. Bodies of the Chambers couple from Montego Bay was found miles from where they were abducted, and three nights ago a New Zealander was shot and killed because he refused to hand over his cell phone to the gunmen.
So Jamaicans who have already fled the hellhole that the island has become, can continue to believe silly surveys that insult the suffering by telling them they’re happy. Jamaicans are getting ready to blow a fuse!
-Kadene
***Sorry, I forgot to add: Tourists come to Jamaica and the Jamaicans smile at/with them because they figure if they don’t smile the tourist won’t be happy. The tourists basically come to smoke ganja in peace, and the many females come for big bamboo sex , so let’s not kid ourselves. But if our people get desperate, they are going to begin to rob, rape and kill them. But no, you think they are happy…that will never happen.
-Kadene
***I am totally in agreement with your letter in today’s Gleaner. You may chuckle but one of my indexes that Jamaica is a happy country is the number of dances or sound systems that play across the island on a daily basis. No matter the problem you will find poor people out in there number doing exactly what Marley prescibed “Forget you trouble and dance”. others go to church and have a wail of a time in the spirit. When you arrived home you sleep well.
The uptowners, the wealthy are always on the social pages and the high-flown party are always over subscribed. Both down and up are always dancing, only happy people dance.
Claude
***Alvin,
it makes you wonder does’nt it?Then again,we should’nt because in one biblical quote it is said that it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than a richman to see the kingdom of heaven.Put another,it is easier for Jamaica to survive a major disaster,God forbid,than the US.We nuh let anything bother us for long;we tun we hand mek fashion,we drink we little “whites”,and we mek ourselves happy.I live in the US,and I can tell you first hand that Americans are nervous,and panicky set of people,who have been spoiled by their make believe lifestyle.I was at a man’s house a few months ago,who was once a big time attorney,raking in millions.His house is in foreclosure,what’s new,his youngest daughter is a “rumhead” soon to be “crackhead”,and he’s suicidal.I spent the better half of an hour doing a Dr.Phill to reassure him that despite his dilema,there is hope.He held me captive because I am a Jamaican,his wife plays only Bob Marley music,but he sees us as a people who know how to survive.
Jamaica,no problem mon.Now if only we could get rid of the politicians and the “shotter”,we would be el numero uno.
scotty
***Mr. Buchanan:
Much as I would like to join you in celebrating this supposed designation of Jamaica as the 3rd “happiest” country on the planet, let me send you a portion of a message that I sent to Mrs. Barbara Gloudon yesterday.
<gloudonb@yahoo.com
Subject: Trepidation about happy people
Mrs. Gloudon:
It has been a while since I have commented directly to you on one of your articles in The Observer. I do want to comment on the one published today.
First off, I need to clarify (and please use your access to Jamaicans to clarify) something about this “Happy People Index.” I had to visit the organization’s website (http://www.happyplanetindex.org/learn/) to obtain additional information on this index. As they say on the website, please note: “The Index doesn’t reveal the ‘happiest’ country in the world. It shows the relative efficiency with which nations convert the planet’s natural resources into long and happy lives for their citizens. The nations that top the Index aren’t the happiest places in the world, but the nations that score well show that achieving, long, happy lives without over-stretching the planet’s resources is possible.”
So, the index is not really saying which country is the “happiest”; rather, it seeks to establish the use that the country makes of the resources at its disposal to sustain life. Hence, it is more an index related to consumption of resources and who can live on the minimum and still “enjoy” life and who are engaged in over-consumption. So, on the surface, it seems to make sense in the Jamaican case: even though things are bad, you would not believe it based on the list recently published of entertainment events in Jamaica last year. Also, it seems to be an index that speaks to “survival skills” (making the best of what we have).>>
Ainsworth (PhD)
Associate Professor
Department of Marketing & Int’l Business
COBA
University of Toledo
***Hi Alvin,
I read your article in today’s gleaner on line before I went to bed and couldnt agree with you more. Money cannot buy happines, as a gospel song says, “money can a house but not a home, medicine but not health, amusement but not happiness”, so money cannot buy happiness.
Life is tough here but we can be happy if we are grateful for what we have.
Regards.
Garfield A. A
Attorney-at-law